HCPC concern: Dishonesty and probity
Facing an HCPC dishonesty allegation: how panels judge honesty and what remediation can show
A dishonesty concern questions your character, not only a single task, which is why it can feel so personal and so frightening. This page explains how the HCPC and its panels decide whether conduct was dishonest, what they weigh when deciding impairment and sanction, and what credible remediation looks like whether you admit the concern, admit part of it or dispute it.
- The two-stage state of mind test in plain English
- Real examples from timesheets to retrospective notes
- What panels weigh for and against you
- Courses mapped to standard 9, be honest and trustworthy
Get the package for £200.90Choose a single course
Last reviewed 17 November 2026
What the HCPC means by a dishonesty concern
For the HCPC, dishonesty is not limited to fraud or theft. It covers any situation where a registrant knowingly gives a false picture, or hides the true one, in a way that ordinary people would regard as dishonest. Probity is the wider idea: being straightforward and trustworthy in everything connected with your professional role, including money, records, references, sickness and what you say to employers and the regulator.
Because health and care work depends on trust, a dishonesty finding goes to the heart of whether the public can rely on what you say and write. That is why panels treat these cases seriously even where no patient came to harm.
Examples of the kind of conduct that leads to a concern
The examples below are illustrative, not real cases.
- A paramedic claims overtime for a shift that finished early, or records a later handover time than the one on the vehicle log.
- A physiotherapist books private patients during contracted NHS hours, or works for an agency while signed off sick from their main employer.
- A radiographer adds a pregnancy check to the record after an incident, so that it looks as if it had been done at the time.
- A biomedical scientist signs off a quality control check that was not run, or alters a log to hide a missed calibration.
- A practitioner psychologist overstates their qualifications or experience in a report, on a website or in a job application.
- An operating department practitioner completes a controlled drugs entry or a count they did not witness.
- An occupational therapist gives an inaccurate account to a manager during an investigation, or omits a previous dismissal from an application.
- A podiatrist or hearing aid dispenser advertises results or credentials in a way likely to mislead.
The standards most often engaged
Standard 9 of the HCPC standards of conduct, performance and ethics, be honest and trustworthy, sits at the centre of most cases. Its wording includes:
- Standard 9.1You must make sure that your conduct justifies the public's trust and confidence in you and your profession.
- Standard 9.2You must be honest about your experience, qualifications and skills.
- Standard 9.3You must take reasonable steps to make sure that any promotional activities you are involved in are accurate and are not likely to mislead.
- Standard 9.4You must declare issues that might create conflicts of interest and make sure that they do not influence your judgement.
- Standard 9.6You must co-operate with any investigation into your conduct or competence, the conduct or competence of others, or the care, treatment or other services provided to service users.
Record-based dishonesty also engages 10.1, “You must keep full, clear and accurate records for everyone you care for, treat or provide other services to.” Hiding an error instead of disclosing it can engage 8.1, which begins “You must be open, honest and candid when something has gone wrong with the care, treatment or other services that you provide”.
Dishonesty, error or poor practice
Not every inaccurate record, claim or statement is dishonest. Many concerns that arrive labelled as dishonesty turn out to be about poor systems, unclear rules, fatigue or a genuine mistake. The difference lies in what you knew at the time. An expenses claim submitted from memory with the wrong mileage is an error if you believed it was right. The same claim, made knowing the journey never happened, is dishonest. Panels are used to drawing that line, and they look at the surrounding evidence, such as whether the pattern was consistent, whether you corrected things once you noticed, and how you responded when asked.
If the concern against you is mainly about accuracy rather than intention, it can help to show that you understand both: why the inaccuracy mattered, and why it was not deliberate. If it was deliberate, the most credible starting point is to say so plainly and focus on why it happened and what has changed.
The statutory ground
Most dishonesty cases are brought on the ground of misconduct under article 22(1)(a) of the Health Professions Order 2001. Where the dishonesty led to a caution or conviction, for example for fraud, the ground is the conviction or caution, and the panel will not go behind the court's findings. The Order also allows action where an entry in the Register “has been fraudulently procured or incorrectly made”, which can arise from false information given when applying.
What you get from a dishonesty course
- Built around standard 9Every module links back to the honesty and trustworthiness standards panels will read your case against.
- Written for HCPC registrantsExamples come from ambulance, imaging, laboratory, theatre, therapy and private practice settings.
- Guided reflectionStructured prompts help you examine pressure, opportunity and rationalisation without writing a confession you do not mean.
- Dated certificate with QR checkEach certificate shows CPD hours and a reference anyone can verify online.
- Instant accessStart straight after payment on any device and work at your own pace.
- 14-day refundIf the course is not right for you, a refund is available under our 14-day policy.
- Secure checkout with Stripe
- Apple Pay and Google Pay on supported devices
- Instant access after payment
- Prices in pounds, no extra charges at checkout
How a dishonesty concern moves through the HCPC process
Dishonesty concerns follow the same route as any other fitness to practise case, but honesty and integrity being in doubt is one of the factors that makes it more likely a concern meets the threshold.
Employer processes often run first. Many dishonesty cases start as a disciplinary investigation about timesheets, expenses or sickness. What you say in that interview may later appear in the HCPC bundle, so accuracy matters from the start. If you are dismissed or restricted because of concerns about conduct, standard 9.5 requires you to tell the HCPC as soon as possible. It sets no fixed number of days.
Interim orders are less common in dishonesty cases than in cases of direct risk to patients, but they can be made where the public interest requires it, for example where there is evidence of ongoing falsification of clinical records. An interim order can last up to 18 months, is reviewed after six months and then every three months, and the panel considering it assesses risk rather than deciding the facts.
Concern received and triage
The HCPC tells you a concern has been raised and checks it is about a registrant, in writing and linked to a statutory ground. Many dishonesty concerns arrive from employers after an internal investigation, or from registrants who self-refer under standard 9.5.
Threshold test
A decision maker asks whether the concern amounts to an allegation that your fitness to practise may be impaired. Doubts about honesty or integrity, a pattern rather than an isolated event, and whether you have already remediated are all part of that judgement.
Investigation and your written response
A case manager gathers evidence such as rotas, claims, audit trails and witness accounts, then drafts allegations. You have 28 days to respond in writing. This is often the first real chance to show insight and remediation.
Investigating Committee Panel
Three panel members meet in private on the papers and ask whether there is a realistic prospect of proving the facts, the ground and current impairment. They do not decide whether you were dishonest.
Final hearing
A Conduct and Competence Committee panel, normally in public, decides the facts on the balance of probabilities, then whether dishonesty is proved, whether that amounts to misconduct, whether you are currently impaired and, if so, what sanction is needed.
Appeal and review
You have 28 days to appeal a final decision. The Professional Standards Authority can also challenge a decision it considers unduly lenient.
What panels look at in a dishonesty case
First: was it dishonest at all
The HCPTS practice note on state of mind sets out a two-stage test drawn from the Supreme Court case Ivey v Genting. The panel first decides what you actually knew or believed about the facts at the time. It then asks whether, given that state of mind, an ordinary decent person would regard the conduct as dishonest. The second stage is objective: it does not matter whether you thought it was acceptable by your own standards, or that colleagues did the same.
This is why the detail of what you knew matters so much. Signing a timesheet you genuinely believed was accurate is different from signing one you knew was wrong. A record made late but clearly marked as a retrospective entry is different from one written to look contemporaneous.
Then: impairment and sanction
The HCPC sanctions policy in effect from 2 March 2026 says dishonesty is likely to lead to more restrictive sanctions. Panels look at how often it happened, for how long, its nature and impact, and whether it was active, such as creating a false document, or passive, such as failing to correct an error. They start with the least restrictive outcome and explain why each lesser option is not enough.
Things that can make a dishonesty case harder
Panels assess honesty during the process as well as in the original conduct. Giving an account to your employer that later changes, contacting witnesses about their evidence, backdating supporting documents or overstating the remediation you have done can all become concerns in their own right. Repeating a denial you know to be untrue can also make it harder to show insight later. If you are unsure how to put something, it is better to take advice and say less than to say something you cannot stand behind.
Equally, the process is not designed to punish. Sanctions are meant to protect the public and maintain confidence in the professions, though they may feel punitive. Financial or reputational consequences for you personally carry little weight, but genuine insight, early remorse and real change do count.
| Factor | What can weigh against you | What can weigh in your favour |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Deliberate, planned or active deception, such as creating a false entry | A single, impulsive omission corrected quickly |
| Frequency and duration | Repeated over months, or a pattern across claims or records | An isolated act with no repetition |
| Impact | Harm or risk to service users, or financial loss to an employer or the public purse | No harm and no gain, or full repayment made early |
| Trust | Breach of trust with vulnerable people, or misleading the investigation itself | Prompt, honest disclosure and co-operation under standard 9.6 |
| Insight | Minimising, blaming others or changing account | Genuine recognition of what went wrong and why it matters to public confidence |
| Remediation | No steps taken, or generic training with no reflection | Targeted learning, changed habits, supervision and objective evidence from others |
| Risk of repetition | No understanding of the pressures that led to it | A clear, tested plan for handling those pressures differently |
Panels, not course providers, decide whether remediation is sufficient. Some dishonesty is so serious that remediation cannot remove the need for a restrictive sanction, and public protection takes priority over insight and remorse.
Check what you know about dishonesty cases
What good remediation looks like for dishonesty
Effective remediation in a dishonesty case is specific, honest about causes and supported by evidence that does not depend on your word alone.
Understand why it happened
Work through the pressures, opportunity and rationalisations behind the conduct, so your reflection explains causes rather than repeating regret.
Rebuild your grasp of probity
Revisit standard 9 across money, conflicts, references and candour, so the panel can see a broader change in judgement.
Fix record habits
Learn how to make, correct and label late entries properly, and why altered records undermine trust in the whole record.
Get claims and absence right
For timesheet, expenses or sickness cases, set out the rules you now follow and the checks you have built in.
Correct the public record
Where the concern involves a CV, reference or advert, show that what you now present about yourself is accurate and checkable.
Show insight a panel can test
Prepare to explain what went wrong, its impact on colleagues and public confidence, and what is different now, including under questioning.
Write a reflective statement that holds up
Turn your learning into a clear, honest statement with dated actions and evidence, not a list of certificates.
Start with the dishonesty and probity package
Five courses chosen for honesty concerns, from understanding the conduct to presenting insight and a reflective statement, at 30% less than buying them separately.
Dishonesty and probity package
£200.90 £287 Save £86.10
- Probity and Honesty for HCPC Registrants
- Dishonesty Remediation: Understanding What Went Wrong
- Falsified and Retrospective Records
- Writing a Reflective Statement for the HCPC
- Demonstrating Insight to an HCPC Panel
Recommended reading and next steps
- Just received an HCPC letterThe responding to an HCPC concern package covers the process, your first steps and your first written response.
- Preparing for the Investigating CommitteeBuild a response, reflective statement and remediation portfolio for the case to answer stage.
- Final hearing listedPrepare evidence, insight and your account for a public hearing.
- Record keeping concernsIf the issue is late or incomplete records rather than deliberate falsification, start here.
- Convictions and conduct outside workFor fraud cautions or convictions and declaring them to the HCPC.
- Confidentiality and dataFor concerns about accessing records without a reason and then misrepresenting why.
- For paramedicsCourses and packages shaped around ambulance practice.
- For biomedical scientistsLaboratory quality, validation and probity in the lab.
- For podiatristsPrivate practice probity, advertising and records.
- How the courses workLessons, quizzes, reflection and your certificate, step by step.
Start building your response today
Understanding the test, the factors and your own account is the foundation of any response. The package brings the core dishonesty courses together, or you can browse the full catalogue.
Dishonesty and probity package
£200.90 £287 Save £86.10
- Probity and Honesty for HCPC Registrants
- Dishonesty Remediation: Understanding What Went Wrong
- Falsified and Retrospective Records
- Writing a Reflective Statement for the HCPC
- Demonstrating Insight to an HCPC Panel
Single courses
Courses for this concern
Buy one course on its own, or take the package and save 30 per cent. Every course ends with a final assessment and a dated certificate.
8 hours CPD
Probity and Honesty for HCPC Registrants
How HCPC panels judge dishonesty, where probity concerns arise across all 15 professions, and how to build insight, safeguards and remediation evidence that speak to trust.
8 hours CPD
Dishonesty Remediation: Understanding What Went Wrong
Deep remediation for HCPC dishonesty concerns: how panels apply the Ivey test, why it happened, impact, insight, objective evidence and a tested relapse-prevention plan.
3 hours CPD
Timesheets, Expenses and Sickness Absence
Honest hours, on-call, bank and agency shifts, mileage, expenses, private billing and sickness absence for all 15 HCPC professions, with fraud law, insight and remediation.
3 hours CPD
Conflicts of Interest, Gifts and Hospitality
Declaring conflicts under standard 9.4, gifts from patients, supplier hospitality, bribery risk, private practice and procurement, with insight and remediation for all 15 professions.
3 hours CPD
Honest CVs, References and Qualifications
Describe your experience and qualifications accurately, write honest references and testimonials, and put things right if an application or reference has led to an HCPC concern.
3 hours CPD
Protected Titles and Practising While Unregistered
Protected titles, lapsed registration and article 39 offences explained, with readmission, return to practice, insight and evidence for HCPC registrants facing a concern.
3 hours CPD
Working Elsewhere While on Sick Leave or Shifts
Second jobs, bank, agency and locum shifts, working during sick leave and the 48-hour limit: what HCPC standard 9 expects and how to remediate an honesty…
5 hours CPD
Falsified and Retrospective Records
Make honest retrospective entries and corrections, avoid back-dating and false checks, and build remediation for an HCPC concern about falsified or altered records.
3 hours CPD
Demonstrating Insight to an HCPC Panel
What HCPC panels mean by insight, how it is judged from the Investigating Committee to review hearings, and how to evidence it with apology, reflection and…
5 hours CPD
Writing a Reflective Statement for the HCPC
Write an honest, evidenced reflective statement for an HCPC concern: insight, causes, impact, standards, concrete changes and evidence, with weak and strong examples.
Save 30 per cent
Dishonesty and probity package
For concerns about honesty: timesheets, sickness absence, records, CVs or what you told an employer or the HCPC.
- Probity and Honesty for HCPC Registrants
- Dishonesty Remediation: Understanding What Went Wrong
- Falsified and Retrospective Records
- Writing a Reflective Statement for the HCPC
- Demonstrating Insight to an HCPC Panel
- Courses
- 5
- Total hours of learning
- 29
- Bought separately
£287- Package price
- £200.90
You save £86.10 (30%). You are enrolled in every course as soon as payment is confirmed.
Questions people ask
Will I be struck off for dishonesty?
Not automatically. The HCPC sanctions policy says dishonesty is likely to lead to more restrictive sanctions, and striking off is a real possibility in serious or repeated cases. But panels must consider the full range, from no action through caution, conditions and suspension, starting with the least restrictive. They weigh how often it happened, for how long, its impact, whether it was active or passive, and your insight and remediation. Nobody can honestly predict an outcome before a panel has heard the case.
What is the Ivey test and how does it apply to HCPC cases?
The HCPTS state of mind practice note applies the test from Ivey v Genting. First, the panel works out what you actually knew or believed about the facts. Second, it asks whether, with that knowledge, an ordinary decent person would see your conduct as dishonest. You do not have to have realised that others would see it that way. That is why a careful, honest account of what you knew at the time is so important.
Should I self-refer to the HCPC?
Standard 9.5 requires you to tell the HCPC as soon as possible if you accept a police caution, are charged with or found guilty of an offence, or are restricted, suspended or dismissed by an employer because of concerns about your conduct or competence. If none of those has happened, self-referral is a judgement call. Many registrants take advice from a union, professional body or regulatory solicitor before deciding. Being open early is generally viewed more favourably than being found out later.
What if I deny that I was dishonest?
You are entitled to dispute the allegation, and the HCPC must prove the facts on the balance of probabilities. The HCPTS guidance says maintaining innocence is not in itself a lack of insight. You can still show learning that does not depend on admitting the disputed facts, for example how you now keep records, check claims or handle conflicts of interest. Courses can support that, but they are not a substitute for legal advice on how to frame a denial.
Can a course help in a dishonesty case?
A course can help you understand the standards, the state of mind test and what panels look for, and give structure to your reflection and remediation. It cannot prove that you are honest. Panels look for insight and changed behaviour backed by evidence from others, such as supervisors, audits or employers. A certificate on its own carries limited weight. Panels decide whether remediation is sufficient, and some dishonesty cannot be fully remediated.
Will a dishonesty finding be public?
Investigating Committee Panel meetings are held in private, on the papers. Final hearings are held in public in all but exceptional circumstances, so if your case reaches that stage the allegations and the panel's decision can become visible to employers and the public. If an interim order is made, the outcome is published but the reasons are not. It is sensible to prepare for that possibility and to think early about what you will tell your employer.
What should I write in a reflective statement about dishonesty?
Explain what happened in your own words, what you knew at the time, and the pressures or reasoning that led to it. Describe the impact on service users, colleagues, your employer and public trust. Then set out what you have learned, what you now do differently and the evidence for that, such as supervision notes, audit results or references. Avoid generic regret and avoid blaming others. If you dispute facts, be clear which parts you accept.
How long does an HCPC dishonesty case take?
There is no fixed timescale. The HCPC aims to finalise allegations within about 12 weeks of starting an investigation, but this can take longer. You then have 28 days to respond, and an Investigating Committee Panel meets after that. If there is a case to answer, a final hearing follows, with the hearing bundle sent at least 42 days before. Complex cases involving employer investigations or police can take considerably longer.
Do I need a solicitor or my union?
You are not required to have representation, but dishonesty allegations carry serious possible outcomes and turn on detailed evidence of what you knew and intended. Many registrants seek advice from their union, professional body or a regulatory solicitor, especially before responding to allegations or admitting facts. Our courses are educational and support your reflection and remediation. They are not legal advice.
